
Hello on the traditional end of summer,
Queue up your favorite Eagles tune or claim to be a “parrothead” even if all you know is “cheeseburger in paradise” or “Margaritaville,” but the last couple months have rocked (pun intended) my musical world. While other members of the Eagles had already passed, the weekend news, informing us that Jimmy Buffet had succumbed to a type of skin cancer was quite a shock. The number of Facebook posts from every corner of the country (and not-surprisingly into the Caribbean) continue to multiply. What seems to be most common are two things: in spite of being worth a billion dollars, he seemed to be genuinely kind and generous, and much like the immortality of parents or grandparents for their children or grandchildren, James William Buffet seemed to establish a sort of immortalized cult following for anyone who enjoyed his music, his well-known brands (be it Margaritaville – restaurants or lodging, and Landshark beer – and reviving the Corona brand also), or his themes of “fins up” or the Coral Reefer, which I read he wanted to establish as a particular strain of weed. Quite the empire for a Mississippi boy, who after being rejected by multiple recording labels founded his own. And yet, while the recognition, the economic empire, and even the seemingly unparalleled generosity have created quite a legacy, and tributes either on Facebook or other bands covering his music will continue, mortality has happened. Mortality is something we admit readily, but avoid even more quickly.
And yet, those jolting moments come. Sometimes too soon; sometimes when we are snapped into reality by a changing circumstance; sometimes, like this weekend, when reminded that even those who seem larger-than-life aren’t. For me, there’s been both the human-family reality of those loved who have passed before I was ready. On the other hand, as a parish pastor, I remember occasions when whether expected or not, helping others face the inevitable morality of a loved one was never easy, even when death was compassionate, ending the suffering that preceded that passing. Even now, there is one death I know occurred, but I was not there to either witness it, nor did I have any interaction beyond an Emergency Room visit. It occurred the summer I completed my Clinical Pastoral Education (CPE) at St. Luke’s Medical Center in my hometown. I was assigned to Pediatrics, Pediatrics Oncology, and Pediatrics ICU. Yet, this did not occur in any of those spaces, but rather in a room in the Emergency area of the center.
This was in the day of beepers, and I was beeped to call my supervisor, who informed me I needed to go to the ER section of the complex to speak with a 23 year old mother whose 2 year-old had received a quite dire medical diagnosis and even more tragic prognosis. I was to go meet her and her son, and offer pastoral care as one of the summer hospital chaplains. At the time I had finished one year of seminary, believed I had a solid faith foundation, and yet, I needed to explain how God might work when a toddler had little chance of living and a mother was facing the imminent death of her first child. I was just a student, but I could say none of that. The shirt I wore telegraphed that somehow I understood God, that I could interpret scripture as well as the why senseless things occurred. To put it accurately, I could not do any of that, and the shirt did little more than corner me into an untenable situation. Perhaps it was that I was in my late 20s; perhaps it was I was more of a realist than I knew; perhaps it was the loss of a brother and my grandmother, and hero, in my early 20s, providing some foundation that supported me beyond scripture. And just maybe it was the prayer of desperation prayed as I walked toward that room that guided me through that 15 minute visit.
The mother greeted me upon my arrival, shaking my hand firmly, and offering the following greeting, “I don’t believe God causes bad things to happen . . .” What an incredible gift from her lips. She did not blame the God she trusted, and it took all the well-meaning, misguided, bullshit platitudes of God choosing to take her child. She made my life exponentially easier before she even knew. And yet the second half of her statement was as much of a Psalmist lament and cry as anything I had studied thus far in my classes. She continued, “But tell me what good comes from this?” I am not sure I thought this at the time, but as I write this now, the word that comes to mind is DAMN!! What to do with that? I looked at her son, who was asleep. He seemed peaceful, and yes, angelic.
I remember swallowing hard, but hopefully not detectably, and I began slowly, “ I not sure what might be positive because it is unfair; it is unreasonable; and it is tragic.” And then I continued, “Two possible things that might be positives are first, we take time for granted and you will not. You will treasure each moment with your son. Second, as a mother, who loves unconditionally, you might find strength you never knew you were capable of. Beyond that, I cannot think of anything. Again, I think it is unfair and unfathomable.” I paused, looking to see her response. Her eyes welled up and tears began to stream down her tanned, but saddened face. I continued a bit further, mostly because of her initial statement. I offered, “I believe in a compassionate and caring God. I believe God hurts as we hurt, and cries as we cry.” I paused, adding, “At least, I sure hope so.” I remember praying for strength, a sense of calmness, and for a promise of as much time as medically possible. I shook her hand, holding it in my own, and I left the room. I had survived that gauntlet, but I felt saddened and inadequate. And yet, I lifted my eyes and whispered thank you. Facing mortality with a two year-old is a tall order for anyone, regardless their piety. That summer was a crash course in living and yes, dying. Weekly, I crossed paths with patients and family members who face their mortality, at times with some advanced inkling, but at other times with a brutality and unexpectedness that would (and did) bring people to their knees. There are no classes; there are no recipe cards; and there are no preparatory vitamins that offer some kind of inoculation from the moment life ends and we face our mortality or that of a loved one.
While the loss of well-known people receive incredible press, and there is the sort of obligatory medical explanation, as well as some additionally information about their particular malady, there are losses as of loved ones daily that go mostly unnoticed, but are as profoundly affecting as when the loss of someone famous occurs. Twenty-six years ago, the world stopped at the tragic loss of the Princess of Wales, Diana Spencer. Her passing caused another musical duo (Elton John and Bernie Taupin) to revise his classic piece “Candle in the Wind.” And yet a quarter century later, our lives continue, and people both enter and exit our lives. While I have noted the occurrence of my 50th high school reunion, I am not sure I noted almost 150 people have passed. Each of them had a family, people who loved them, others they affected. Life is an incredible gift given, and yet fragile and fleeting. I realize clearly my days are numbered, and the promise of tomorrow is no promise at all. .
While I too am saddened that my bucket list line that was “see a Jimmy Buffet Concert” will go infilled, I am forever grateful that my Dana classmate, Michael Keenan, introduced me to the incredibly original and unapologetic Jimmy Buffet. While the beer I will raise is not a Landshark, I will raise a Moosehead, the other thing Mr. Keenan introduced me to. To that Raiders floor on Four North Holling Hall the fall of 1979. The changes in attitudes and latitudes have been many since then, but on this Labor Day, fins up and to another day in this mortal world.
Thank you for reading.
Dr. Martin









